探究LLM考Bar

美国有188所由美国律师协会(ABA)认可的法学院,其中除了一所The Judge Advocate General's School为美国陆军的军校之外,另外187所法学院校每年大约招收3.6万多名的全日制法律学生及约7000名的选读法律学生.所有被ABA认可的法学院,其毕业生均可以参加美国各州的律师考试,大约80%以上的法律学生都以选择律师为主要就业出路,约10%强的法律毕业生进入司法体系或选择其他公职.要获得美国律师协会的认可,法学院必须达到该协会规定的标准,包括学校设施、图书馆藏书、师生比例、课程安排等.

美国大约有13个州允许LLM学生考bar(美国州级律师资格),这13个州中经济比较发达、其bar比较有实用价值的是CA和NY,其中绝大多数的LLM毕业生会选择考NY的bar。不一定要在某个特定的州读LLM,可以到任何一所美国律协认证的法学院(ABA Approved Law School)读LLM,然后到那个允许考bar的州去参加考试。

允许LL.M.报考的个州:
Arizona, California, Connecticut, Michigan, New Hampshire, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia, Paula等

各州对考试资格要求各有不同,加州好像是有多少年实际经验就行,哪怕从来没上过法学院也可以,但好像需要有外国律师执照。德州对单纯读个LLM不能考,但是如果在其他国家执业5年以上,就可以考。

首先,考Bar从理论上来说,是为J.D所准备的,而要考Bar的话,必须是要ABA承认的法学院。应该说,ABA认证法学院也基本上完全是从JD学位来认证的,而和这个学校的LLM并没有多大关系。简单的说,要考bar而进ABA认证的法学院,是指进了它的JD才能保证你获得考Bar的资格。

接下来我们进入重要的问题,就是有关International LLM Student考bar的规定。第一个要澄清的事情是,各个洲都有自己的Bar,因此,作为International Student要考bar,首先要知道哪些洲是可以允许外国人来做自己的律师的,而不是看这个学校是不是让你考Bar。简单说,国际学生考Bar,首先是看哪些洲允许国际学生考。那么,哪些洲允许国际学生考呢,有一下这些:

Arizona, California, Connecticut, Michigan, New Hampshire, New York, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Tennessee, and Virginia

第二个问题,或者说第二个要件是,当你找到了允许你考Bar的洲,还要满足你读的是ABA认证的学位。那么上面已经说了,ABA认证学校是根据JD来分的,那么我们LLM学生要考Bar就不可以单单看学校了,ABA是把JD以外的所有学位,按照学位来认证的。下面就是最重要的东西,ABA认证的LLM学位有哪些,这里我给大家一个ABA网站上的表格:

Alabama, University of, LL.M.
Boston University, LL.M.
Brigham Young University, LL.M.
California-Davis, University of, LL.M.
California-Hastings, LL.M.
California-Los Angeles, University of, LL.M.
California Western, LL.M./M.C.L.
Case Western Reserve University, LL.M. Catholic University of America, LL.M.
Connecticut, University of, LL.M.
Denver, University of, LL.M.
Duke University, LL.M.
Duquesne University Georgetown University, LL.M.
Golden Gate University, LL.M.
Hawaii, University of, LL.M.
Hamline University, LL.M.
Houston, University of, LL.M.
Howard University, LL.M.
Indiana University-Indianapolis, LL.M.
Michigan State University, Detroit College, LL.M.
Miami, University of, LL.M.
Minnesota, University of, LL.M.
Pace University, LL.M. Saint Louis University, LL.M
St. Mary's University, LL.M.
San Diego, University of, LL.M.
San Francisco, University of, LL.M.
Santa Clara University, LL.M.
6n\u0018| W#P\u0006`\u001EX:P)P Seattle University, LL.M.
Southern California, University of, LL.M.
Suffolk University, LL.M.
Temple University, LL.M.
Touro Collge, LL.M.
Tulsa, University of, LL.M.
Valparaiso University, LL.M.
Vanderbilt University, LL.M.
Wake Forest University, LL.M.
Washington and Lee University, LL.M.
Washington University, LL.M.
\u0017A8F*M G\u0018c\u0013_3K\u0014^ Whittier School of Law, LL.M.
\u0017a u,F3u\u0013l\u0013W#Y4E William & Mary, College of, LL.M.

另外,除了这些LLM学位以外,ABA对于其他学位也有认证,主要有JSD,SJD,JM之类的。那么这里再附上ABA认证的所有学位的列表(总表,光LLM的话可以看楼上的贴),以供大家参考:
`

Admiralty/Marine Affairs\
Tulane University, LL.M.
Washington, University of, LL.M.

Agriculture Law\
University of Arkansas-Fayetteville, LL.M.
American and International Legal Practice
Loyola University-Los Angeles

American Law for Foreign Lawyers
Florida State University, LL.M.

Asian and Comparative Law
Washington, University of, LL.M.; Ph.D.

Banking, Corporate, and Finance Law/Financial Services/Securities\
Boston University, LL.M.
Chicago-Kent-Illinois Institute of Technology, LL.M.
Fordham University, LL.M.
Georgetown University, LL.M.
New York University, LL.M.
Wayne State University, LL.M.
Widener University, LL.M.

Bankruptcy Law
St. John's University, LL.M.

Biotechnology and Genomics\
Arizona State University, LL.M.

Business Law
Loyola University-Chicago, L.L.M.; M.J.(
San Diego, University of, LL.M.

Business and Taxation
Capital University, LL.M.
Pacific-McGeorge, University of, LL.M.

Child and Family Law.
Chicago-Kent College of Law, IIT, LL.M.
Loyola University-Chicago, LL.M.; M.J.

Clinical Legal Education
Temple University, LL.M.

Comparative Law/Comparative Legal Studies/Comparative Jurisprudence/Comparative Legal Thought
Florida, University of, LL.M.
Indiana University-Bloomington, M.C.L.
John Marshall Law School, LL.M.
Miami, University of, LL.M.
New York University, M.C.J.
Pennsylvania State University, LL.M.
Samford University, M.C.L.[
Tulane University, M.C.L.
Tulsa, University of, LL.M.
Yeshiva University, LL.M.$

Criminal Law
Buffalo, State University of NY, Univ. at, LL.M.

Dispute Resolution
George Washington, LL.M
Missouri-Columbia, University of, LL.M
Oregon, University of (Masters)
Pepperdine University, M.D.R., LL.M.

Education Law
Franklin Pierce Law Center, M.E.L.

Employee Benefits
John Marshall Law School, LL.M.

Energy, Environment/Natural Resources
Denver, University of, LL.M.
George Washington University, LL.M.
Golden Gate University, LL.M.
Houston, University of, LL.M.
Lewis and Clark College, LL.M.
Pace University, LL.M.; S.J.D.
Pacific-McGeorge, University of, LL.M.
Tulane University, LL.M.
Utah, University of, LL.M.
Vermont Law School, LL.M.; M.S.E.L.

Entertainment and Media Law
Southwestern University, LL.M.

Estate Planning
Miami, University of, LL.M.
Missouri-Kansas City, University of, J.D./LL.M.

General or As Approved
Alabama, University of, LL.M.
California-Berkeley, University of , LL.M.; J.S.D.
California-Davis, University of , LL.M.
Cardozo School of Law, LL.M.
Catholic University of America, LL.M.
Chicago, University of, LL.M.; S.J.D.; M.C.L; D.C.L.
Cleveland State University, LL.M.
Columbia University, LL.M.; J.S.D.
Cornell University, LL.M.; J.S.D.
Emory University, LL.M.
George Mason, J.M. (for nonlawyers)
George Washington University, LL.M.
Georgetown University, LL.M.; S.J.D.
Georgia, University of, LL.M.\
Harvard University, LL.M.
Illinois, University of, LL.M.; J.S.D.
Indiana University-Bloomington, LL.M.
Indiana University-Indianapolis, S.J.D.
Louisiana State University, LL.M.; M.C.L.
Michigan, University of, LL.M.; M.C.L.; S.J.D.
Missouri-Kansas City, University of, LL.M.
New York University, LL.M.; J.S.D.
New York University, J.S.D.
Pennsylvania, University of, LL.M.; M.C.L.; S.J.D.
San Diego, University of, LL.M.
Southern Methodist University, LL.M.; S.J.D.
Stanford University, J.S.D.; J.S.M.(
Temple University, LL.M.
Texas, University of, LL.M.
Touro College, LL.M.
Tulane University, LL.M.; S.J.D.
Virginia, University of, LL.M.; S.J.D.
Wayne State University, LL.M.
Wisconsin, University of, LL.M.; S.J.D.; M.L.I.
Yale University, LL.M.; J.S.D.


Global Technology
Suffolk University, LL.M.

Government and Public Policy
Pacific-McGeorge, University of, LL.M.
Government Administration and Regulation\
Albany Law School of Union University, LL.M.

Health Law
Albany Law School of Union University, LL.M.
DePaul University, LL.M.
Houston, University of, LL.M.
Loyola University-Chicago, LL.M.; S.J.D.; M.J.
Nova Southeastern University, M.H.L.
Quinnipiac University
Saint Louis University, LL.M..K
Seton Hall University, LL.M.
Widener University, LL.M.; S.J.D.; M.J.; D.L

Indigenous Law
Arizona, University of, LL.M.
Tulsa, University of, LL.M.

Insurance Law
Connecticut, University of, LL.M.
Intellectual Property/Technology/Information Technology Law
Akron, University of, LL.M.
Albany Law School of Union University, LL.M.
Boston University, LL.M.
Cardozo, School of Law, LL.M.
Chicago-Kent College of Law, LL.M.
DePaul University, LL.M.
Franklin Pierce Law Center, LL.M.
George Mason University, LL.M.
George Washington University, LL.M.
Golden Gate University, LL.M.
Houston, University of, LL.M.
John Marshall Law School, LL.M.; M.S.
Santa Clara University, LL.M.
Suffolk University, LL.M.
Thomas M. Cooley Law School, LL.M.
Washington University, LL.M.
Washington, University of, LL.M.

International/International and Comparative Law/Comparative and International Law/International Legal Studies
Albany Law School of Union University, LL.M.
American University, LL.M.d
Chicago-Kent-Illinois Institute of Technology, LL.M.(
Georgetown University, LL.M.
George Washington University, LL.M.
Golden Gate University, LL.M.; S.J.D.
Hofstra University, LL.M.
Iowa, University of, LL.M.
Miami, University of, LL.M.
New York University, LL.M.
Notre Dame, University of, LL.M.
Pittsburg, University of, J.S.D.
Puerto Rico, University of, LL.M.
Pittsburgh, University of, LL.M.
San Diego, University of, LL.M.\
Southern Methodist University, LL.M.
Stetson University, LL.M.
St. Mary's University, LL.M.
Santa Clara University, LL.M.
Tulane University, LL.M.
Willamette University, LL.M.

International Business and Trade Law/Transnational Business Practice
Arizona, University of, LL.M.
Fordham University, LL.M.
John Marshall Law School, LL.M.\
New York University, LL.M.
Pacific-McGeorge, University of, LL.M.
San Francisco, University of, LL.M.
Stetson University, LL.M.

International Economic Law
Houston, University of, LL.M.

International Environmental Law
Washington, University of, LL.M.

Intercultural/International Human Rights
Notre Dame, University of, LL.M.; S.J.D.
St. Thomas University, LL.M.

International Taxation
New York University, LL.M.
Regent University, LL.M.
St. Thomas University, J.S.D.

Inter-American Law
Miami, University of, LL.M.
Judicial Process
Virginia, University of, LL.M.

Labor Law/Employment Law
Georgetown University, LL.M.
New York University, LL.M.
Wayne State University, LL.M.

Law and Economics
George Mason University, LL.M.

Law and Government/Procurement
American University, LL.M.
George Washington University, LL.M.

Law, Religion, and Culture
Samford University, LL.M.; S.J.D.

Legal Studies
Albany Law School of Union University, LL.M.
Arizona State University, LL.M.
Connecticut, University of , LL.M.\
Northwestern University, M.S.

Litigation/Trial Advocacy/Advocacy
Georgetown University, LL.M. (Clinical Fellows)
George Washington University, LL.M.

Military Law
Judge Advocate General's School, LL.M.

Ocean and Coastal Law
Miami, University of, LL.M.

Professional Studies in Law
Touro College, M.P.S.L.

Real Estate/Land Development
John Marshall, LL.M.
Miami, University of, LL.M.\
Duke University, S.J.D.:
Indiana University-Bloomington, S.J.D.
Northwestern University, LL.M.; S.J.D.
Southern Methodist University, S.J.D.
Washington University, J.S.D.

Securities Regulation
Georgetown University, LL.M.

Sustainable International Development\
Washington, University of, LL.M.

Taxation
Alabama, University of, LL.M.
Baltimore, University of, LL.M.
Boston University, LL.M.
Capital University, LL.M.
Case Western Reserve University, LL.M.\
Chapman University, LL.M.
Chicago-Kent-Illinois Institute of Technology, LL.M.\
Denver, University of, LL.M.
DePaul University, LL.M.
Florida, University of, LL.M.; S.J.D.
Georgetown University, LL.M.
Golden Gate University, LL.M.
Houston, University of, LL.M.9
John Marshall Law School, LL.M.
Loyola Marymount University-Los Angeles, LL.M.
Miami, University of, LL.M.
Missouri-Kansas City, University of, LL.M.
New York Law School, LL.M.
New York University, LL.M.
Northwestern University, LL.M.
Pacific-McGeorge, University of, LL.M.
San Diego, University of, LL.M.
Southern Methodist University, LL.M.
Temple University, LL.M.
Thomas M. Cooley Law School, LL.M.
Villanova University, LL.M.
Washington University, LL.M.\
Washington, University of, LL.M.
Wayne State University, LL.M.

Trial Advocacy
Temple University, LL.M.

Tribal Policy, Law and Government
Arizona State University, LL.M.

Urban Affairs/Urban Studies
Missouri-Kansas City, University of, LL.M.
Washington University, LL.M

附:纽约州律师资格考试的经历

一、律考报名

    在2003年8月至2004年5月期间,我在美国弗吉尼亚州的Washington and Lee University 攻读LLM。我参加的是2004年7月份的纽约BAR考试,填表报名大约是在2004年3月份。

可报考的州:大约有十多个州均允许外国学生报名,其中包括纽约州、加州、弗吉尼亚州等。

报名资格(纽约州):对于一个来自中国(大陆法系国家)的学生:需要在中国法学院学习3年或以上;需要在美国法学院选修至少20学分且需要选修至少二门基干课。

须送交的资料(纽约州):填写从网上(www.nybarexam.org )下载的报名表;提交由国内法学院出具的成绩单、毕业证、学位证证明(我用的是申请入学时剩下的,先见之明嘛!);美国法学院负责教务的老师出具的公证书;美国法学院的成绩单。

[需要说明和强调一下,美国法学院的成绩单一般要等到毕业后才能取得,所以在离校前一定要向学院负责成绩的老师递交申请,请其于成绩出来时将一份正式成绩单邮寄纽约州律师考试委员会。当然,保险一点的作法是,让其同时给自己也寄上三五份,自己再向律考委寄一份,双保险。我在考试前2周还未收到准考证,打电话才得知律考委未收到我的成绩单(可能是寄丢了)!把人折腾个半死才算未前功尽弃,前后之鉴,望后来者慎之]

二、BAR/BRI的律考培训

5月8日参加了隆重的毕业典礼。之后,我坐上灰狗(greyhound)巴士,奔赴纽约州首府ALBANY(奥伯尼)。提前10天上网订的票,便宜了不少,90多美元的只付了60元左右。有个大学同学在ALBANY攻读经济学博士,事先他已帮我sub-lease了一间房。之所以提前来到考试地ALBANY,是因为BAR/BRI在ALBANY有个培训点, 在ALBANY LAW SCHOOL。

BAR/BRI在律考培训领域的霸主地位,相当于中国移动在中国移动通讯方面的地位。我是在2003年10月左右交了100美金的定金,此定金的交付,可起到订死培训费的作用,以及可以同时免费获得BAR/BRI的法学院学习辅导用书(内容和和律考培训书基本一致)。培训费可是每年都上涨的。培训费当然是贵的,2500美元(含书费)左右。

除了牛人之外,参加BAR/BRI是非常必要的。理由在于:美国学生大多也参加此培训(这理由够充分了吧);如果你上的是LLM,那就太有必要参加此培训了,此2个月的培训,可使只在美国法学院呆了一年的你,感觉和读了3年的JD的差距大大地缩小了。

在5月初离校前即可拿到BAR/BRI的两本long book. 其余的书是在5月23号左右(培训开始前2天)在ALBANY拿到的。总共有9本书左右。

接下来的不到两个月的时间,便是每天上午骑着一辆从沃尔玛买的中国制造的山地车,去ALBANY LAW SCHOOL听上3个多小时的课,再回到住处,按课程表复习、预习、做题。

那是一段令人身心疲惫,但又令人备感幸福以至难以忘怀的日子。人说,经历是一笔财富,不假。

又必要谈一下身心的调济。我是喜欢跑步的。ALBANY的三条大道和若干小道,在两个月的时间内,被我用脚丈量了若干次。这其中的好处在于,走马观花的了解美国的风土民情,尤其是美国黑人的贫困生活状态,以此也可激励及鞭策自我。

三、考试

所有的外国人都在ALBANY参加纽约州的考试。所以请至少提前2个月订酒店。

考试分二天。有些州第一天是Local day,第二天是Multistate day。有些州(如纽约)相反。此一差别使得一些学生可参加两个州的考试。

Multistate day 考的全为四选一单选题,而且全为案例题。共200道,上午100道,下午100道,各3个小时。分七大块:宪法,合同法,侵权法, 财产法,刑法及刑诉,信托与继承(TRUST AND WILLS),证据法。

Local day 考的是纽约本州的法律,包含20来门课的内容。题形:50道案例单选题;5个案例分析;1个相当于MEMO的实务题。上下午各3个小时,时间比较紧张。

成绩是在4月多后(即11月中下旬)公布的。可以在网上查看自己是否通过。

纽约州律考的通过率在65%左右,但国际学生(其中部分是读了3年的JD)的通过率却只有20%左右。

顺带说一下,律考每年进行二次,一次在二月,一次在七月。除了这个大考之外,要申请执照还需要参加MPRE,即律师执业道德考试,一年也是考两次,相对来说,内容简单,认真自学准备10天就可通过,可以在读LLM期间就参加该考试。

美勤精英顾问